Cycle Idle RPG
A free idle RPG with the genuine article — true 1:1 offline progression — attached to a retention design that keeps demanding you come back and play minigames by hand.
6.5 / 10
The Wanderer reading room
Game Reviews
Idle RPGs, MMOs, browser games and mobile RPGs, taken apart properly. Every review carries a score out of 10, what the game does well, what it does badly, and the kind of player it is actually for.
Browse the reviews
Darkest Dungeon II
Red Hook rebuilt Darkest Dungeon as a roguelite road trip instead of a long campaign, and three years later the review corpus still splits almost exactly down that line — not a launch controversy that faded, but a genre identity change some fans never made peace with.
7.5 / 10
Days Gone
An open-world zombie survival game with a genuine cult following that grew after release — launched on PC in 2021 with one of the most severe, best-documented data-collection controversies this library has seen, since resolved with an opt-out but still shaping how the game is remembered.
7.5 / 10
DayZ
The game that arguably invented the modern survival genre from an ARMA 2 mod is still running, still brutal, and still dividing its own reviews between people who lived through its infamous five-year alpha and people just discovering how unforgiving it remains today.
6.5 / 10
Dead as Disco
A beat-'em-up where every punch lands on the beat, 97.5% positive, half a million copies sold — and an Early Access launch so thin that its critics and its fans are describing the same game accurately.
8.5 / 10
DeadboySkeleton
A cheap third-person action game built as an explicit fan tribute to the hip-hop collective TeamSesh — reviewed on its complete 35-review English sample, most of which turned out to be one-word fandom slogans, with the real, substantive verdict hiding underneath them.
5.5 / 10
Dead by Daylight
Ten years, 38 DLC packs and 924,876 reviews later, the complaint isn't the licensed horror store — DLC appears in nine of a hundred negative reviews. It's each other.
7 / 10
DEADLINE DELIVERY
A short, stylish drift-racing game about a bomb-strapped monkey mail truck, loved by fans who call its unforgiving handling a fair skill curve and criticized just as forcefully by players who call the same physics broken — with a verified, punishing completion curve and three and a half months of developer silence underneath the debate.
6.5 / 10
Dear Magical Girls
A free, story-driven tower defense game about an overworked magical girl reshaping a living barrier to hold back monster waves — short, and so consistently compared to Madoka Magica by its own players that the comparison reads as a shared, spontaneous consensus rather than marketing.
8.5 / 10
Deepcore Mining
A cheap, honestly-scoped mining incremental about drilling a low-poly planet layer by layer for roughly two hours — well liked by its first handful of reviewers, with one detailed bug report worth taking seriously before you buy.
6.5 / 10
Deep Rock Galactic
Ghost Ship Games built a co-op shooter around a cave that isn't scenery — it's a resource you carve your own path through, and the four classes exist specifically to argue about how.
8.7 / 10
Deep Sea Idle: Infinity Abyss
A submarine incremental where automated torpedoes, plasma and lightning chain across the screen while you mine the abyss for resources — a short, satisfying loop for most of its early reviewers, with one detailed complaint about a mid-run power-fantasy slump and an achievement curve that backs it up.
6.5 / 10
Delta Force
A generous, well-made free shooter whose most-upvoted review isn't about the shooting at all — it's about the kernel-level anti-cheat that reviewers say keeps running after the game is uninstalled.
6.5 / 10
DELTARUNE
98.1% positive across 127,913 reviews, and every future chapter is a free update — an RPG that is both one of the best-reviewed games on Steam and an argument about what a full-price purchase should buy you.
9 / 10
Dig For Your Lives
A free, chaotic co-op dig-and-defend game where up to four friends mine for loot by day and fend off zombies by night — reviewed on its complete English review sample, which reads as a genuinely fun prototype whose launch-week bugs a solo developer has been patching almost daily.
6.5 / 10
Directive 8020
Supermassive set up the best premise they've ever had — a shapeshifting alien aboard a crashed colony ship, where the horror is not trusting the crew — and then spent the second half forgetting to use it.
6.5 / 10
Dispatch
The former Telltale team proved the choice-driven narrative game was never dead, just badly run — four million copies, a BAFTA and 97.5% across 181,617 reviews, most of whose complaints are about a release schedule that has since ended.
8.5 / 10
Dispel Dark
A tiny, atmospheric roguelite built on one sharp idea — your torch is both your only light and your only weapon, so every swing costs you visibility — that's landed a perfect early score across two separate language communities in its first two days.
7.5 / 10
DRAGON BALL: Sparking! ZERO
A gorgeous arena fighter sitting at 85% lifetime — and 30% across its last hundred reviews, because a DLC released six days ago has Ultimate Edition owners saying they're being charged twice.
6.5 / 10
Dreadweave
A post-Soviet extraction horror shooter where a creature hunts you by your heartbeat — reviewed on its full English review sample, a dated patch that directly addressed the mechanic's loudest complaint, and a real mismatch between its co-op marketing history and its shipped build.
6.5 / 10
Dverghold
A first-person, grid-based dungeon crawler built squarely in the tradition of Dungeon Master and Eye of the Beholder, paired with a Darkest Dungeon-style basecamp and an original dungeon synth soundtrack — a week into Early Access, every single review it has is positive.
8 / 10
Dwarf Delve
A mining extraction roguelite from a solo developer that launched broken enough to earn a "Mostly Negative" tag — softlocks, an unexplained tutorial, and rough performance — while simultaneously earning some of the most sympathetic, patient negative reviews this library has seen, because the developer has been visibly fighting to fix it in real time.
5 / 10
EA SPORTS FC 26
Everyone expects the complaint about this game to be Ultimate Team. It isn't — Ultimate Team appears in 14 of its hundred most-helpful negative reviews, and memory leaks, resetting settings and save-wiping crashes appear in far more.
5.5 / 10
Eastward
A gorgeous pixel-art adventure with some of the most detailed, distinctive sprite work and sound design in the genre, wrapped around a story a large and consistent share of its own reviewers say loses the plot somewhere in its middle stretch.
7 / 10